MATLAB Answers

How to understand the simulation results using basic components in Simscape->foundation library-->mechanical?

조회 수: 1(최근 30일)
liqun fang
liqun fang 2021년 6월 11일
편집: liqun fang 2021년 6월 14일
Q1:As shown in the figure below, based on the actual physical process, the top result spring should be elongated and the bottom result should be shortened. However, the simulation results show that both springs are shortened. Why???
As shown in the figure below, based on the actual physical process, we have F=P_A*S_A-P_B*S_B=16000-10000=6000N.
According Newton's laws, we can deduce the following figure. So the scoep2 and scope 7 will display positive 6000N.
But the simulation result is different from Newton's law. The scope2 is positive 6000N and is right. The scope7 is negative 7000N and is different from positive 6000N. So the simulation disobey Newton's law . Why???


Yifeng Tang
Yifeng Tang 2021년 6월 12일
Hello Liqun,
The direction in Simscape is usually defined by the movement (towards/away) of R port with respect to the C port. One common beginner mistake is to confuse left/right on Simulink canvas as positive/negative. Flip a block on canvas does not imply direction change. However, switch R and C port connection can flip the sign of almost all sensor readings.
The documentation of each block defines which direction is regarded as positive. You may refer to those to make sure you are modeling what you have in mind.
Another good resource is the Simscape Onramp, available starting R2021a:
Hope this helps.
  댓글 수: 3
liqun fang
liqun fang 2021년 6월 14일
Thank you for your reply again. Actually , I can understand your model that you create for my plobelm. For node C in the figure below, considering the positive direction, the node C balance equation is equal to F1=F2+F3. It looks like KCL in the Principles of Electric Circuits. That's right as you explained and I can understand.
But for my Q2 , the basic model is hydraulic cylinder. Considering the generalized node C, based on the KCL, we can get the results as you explained and the simulation results displayed. And the scope7 should be negative 7000N. I can understand the results, but what I mean is that it violates the actual process . Just like the actual physical process ,the below figure is just right. So the scope7 should be positive 6000N. That is my confusion.

댓글을 달려면 로그인하십시오.




Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by