finding missing value using interpolation

조회 수: 1 (최근 30일)
S.Sil
S.Sil 2015년 11월 11일
편집: S.Sil 2016년 12월 5일
Here is the data for the diameter and power of a hydraulic impulse

답변 (2개)

Brandon
Brandon 2015년 11월 11일
The interp1 function does not allow for extrapolation. 2.01 is outside your domain for 0 to 1.92

dpb
dpb 2015년 11월 11일
Yeah, your second desired location is outside the range of the input and interp1 won't extrapolate unless it's ordered to--use
>> interp1(Diameter,Power,Given_Diameter,'linear','extrap')
ans =
2.0000 0.2367
>>
  댓글 수: 2
dpb
dpb 2015년 11월 11일
Looking at the relationship shown by plotting the above, looks like
interp1(Diameter,Power,Given_Diameter,'spline','extrap')
might be a better approximation than linear in this case as long as don't go very far outside the range ( always a risky proposition, anyway).
dpb
dpb 2015년 11월 11일
>> plot(Diameter,Power,'x-') % original data showing points
>> hold on
>> pInterp1=interp1(Diameter,Power,Given_Diameter,'linear','extrap');
>> plot(Given_Diameter,pInterp1,'*') % linear interpolation
>> pSpln=interp1(Diameter,Power,[0:.1:2],'spline');
>> plot([0:.1:2],pSpln,'r-') % spline interpolation of original
>> pSplExt=interp1(Diameter,Power,Given_Diameter,'spline','extrap');
>> plot(Given_Diameter,pSplExt,'or') % and those interp/extrap values
>> [pInterp1;pSplExt] % compare the two choices...
ans =
2.0000 0.2367
2.0000 0.2465
>>
NB: the advantage of the spline over the linear is likely that it shows some effect of the curvature apparent in the data while the linear continues at the same slope as the last two points thus predicting lower value.
A quadratic looks like a reasonable try but if you fit it and add to the above you'll see it has a minimum before the last data point as it tries to minimize the whole curve equally.
Perhaps, depending on what it actually is, there may be reason to use a decaying exponential instead?

댓글을 달려면 로그인하십시오.

태그

아직 태그를 입력하지 않았습니다.

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by