A faster findsignal method

조회 수: 5(최근 30일)
Matt Flax
Matt Flax 2021년 10월 17일
댓글: Matt Flax 2021년 10월 20일
findsignal implements a method for finding the best similairty between two signals. findsignal is slow.
Is there a faster way to execute findsignal ?
  댓글 수: 2
Matt Flax
Matt Flax 2021년 10월 20일
Nice site! The DFT method is good for longer signals.For shorter signals this is more efficient : https://au.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/100893-findsimilarity
I also tested your code sing gpuArray, however that significantly slows down the computation for shorter signals as well !

댓글을 달려면 로그인하십시오.


Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson 2021년 10월 17일
Maybe. It would not astonish me if parts if it could be rewritten to use an available GPU.
However... the algorithm already invokes two mex functions to improve performance, so you might be hard-pressed to find a more efficient algorithm.
The algorithm involves normalization of signals, and involves calculating dynamic time warping (dtw) https://www.mathworks.com/help/signal/ref/dtw.html to try to find the best match. The dtw is one of the portions done as mex.
You might be able to find a different algorithm, but you would need to ask whether it is doing the same job as findsignal() is doing. For example, some people might be satisfied with xcorr() https://www.mathworks.com/help/matlab/ref/xcorr.html but that does not have the same behaviour of trying to find the best possible place for the signals to fit together including stretching.

Matt Flax
Matt Flax 2021년 10월 17일
I see, thanks for the information. Yes, xcorr will not work because it has no form of error or difference measure.
The core algorithm of interest is (the same as findsignal.m) the algorithm used in Waveform Similarity Overlap Add (WSOLA), specifically the algorithm for similarity searching : https://github.com/flatmax/gtkiostream/blob/master/src/WSOLA.C#L62
Which can be written in Matlab like so to find a similar signal to s in the vector y :
It is interesting that when profiling the above non-mex code, it is similar in speed to the findsignal.m algorithm. The buffer code is heavy on memory allocation which is slow. The rms method is not a mex code.
It would seem that there is possibly scope to improve the speed somewhere ?




Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by