image thumbnail

Synchronizing metronomes

버전 1.1.0.1 (9.78 KB) 작성자: Guy Rouleau
The 5 pendulums, in a vectorized approach

다운로드 수: 2K

업데이트 날짜: 2016/9/1

라이선스 보기

I do not have the perfect solution, but I want to add little something in the challenge. Simulating that kind of coupled non-linear system seems to be tricky in Simulink®.
At first I thought this challenge was going to be easy, I assembled a SimMechanics model, clicked play… but the pendulums are not synchronizing, as mentioned by Parasar in his post.

Then I thought, let’s try with Simulink®. I implemented the equations provided and then face two choices:

- By default, the coupling of the equations results in an algebraic loop. I try to let the algebraic loop solver resolving the algebraic loop, and the results are similar to the ones from SiMemchanics™. It looks like the Simulink® algebraic loop solver is doing a job similar to the SimMechanics™ solver. I cannot explain the exact reason, my guess is that the algebraic loop solver removes the non-linearity that makes the pendulums synchronize in real life.

- My standard way to remove algebraic loops is to introduce a delay in the feedback path. In that case, the pendulums synchronize but the model becomes instable. The maximum sample time of the Simulink® solver must be adjusted to an appropriate value to obtain an acceptable tradeoff between synchronization and stability.

I implemented the model using a vector approach. It allows easily changing the number of pendulums and modifying the algorithm.

From what I understand, the pendulum equations are non-linear and it should not be required to add any nonlinear limits, like bump stops in a metronome.

I hope Seth will provide explanations on why no one has been able to obtain the synchronization using SimMechanics™.

Guy

인용 양식

Guy Rouleau (2022). Synchronizing metronomes (https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/21748-synchronizing-metronomes), MATLAB Central File Exchange. 검색됨 .

MATLAB 릴리스 호환 정보
개발 환경: R2008b
모든 릴리스와 호환
플랫폼 호환성
Windows macOS Linux

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!